By the way roa, how would you feel if your 99 euro purchase of fungen from June randomly out of the blue got revoked unilaterally if k00gar happened to swing sideways one of these days and feel like one of your bug reports or comments about how the AI should not go from 0 to 100 and have some form of human input is taken as an insult to them? What then huh? Can literally happen at any point based on the current licensing setup. Will you just take it and still gospel for them? Fucking unreal honestly. And that’s just 99, now extrapolate to 250. Or the 75 yearly which is anyway close to the 99 you paid for lifetime just two and a bit months ago.
If this shit was free then it would be different. Then it would just be them being spineless and not taking criticism well. Whatever, happens so many times on the internet. But this is not just a paid product, it’s a product you pay out of your ass for right now. I don’t think what he’s doing is even in full legality with the french/EU laws. You can’t just offer paid licenses for your product AND be the person in charge of revoking the licensing. That’s a huge conflict of interest, even assuming the best intentions of sticking to your TOS.
I see. I would like a new and updated scripting tool. OFS is great and works fantastic. But a newer version, modern ui, more features etc. would be amazing. I’d even pay for it. If somebody puts a lot of work and time into something, they deserve something back. Price should be reasonable of course. 250 for one purchase, 75 yearly sub or 25 monthly sub seems way too steep imo. A fair price for compensation is absolutely reasonable though.
And if the license can get revoked at any time, that creates too much uncertainty. I don’t really get the point why they make it sub based anyway. A one time purchase would be the best and most fair solution. In case it goes well and there is a lot of interest, keep building the app, eventually release a 2.0, ask for a small price to get the update, or offer a discount for anybody who has version 1.0.
That’s how I’d approach something like this. I am not developer though, I have no idea about coding. I only know it takes serious skill and time.
Pretty unfortunate situation it seems like. I hope everybody who paid for it can still use it and they don’t get their license terminated.
You are free to download and use FunGen Free (without the Pro AI models).
No one can take FunGen away from you. If you have a copy, you can always restore it. The one-month license expires after one month.
This isn’t a service that simply stops working if you don’t log in.
Not sure why @Rriik is trying to provoke people and spread misinformation.
There is no misinformation in what i said. If you paid for the AI you can get your rights to use the AI revoked at any moment (and therefore the rights to your purchase) according to the current licensing. Open the LICENSE-SUPPLEMENTAL.txt file in any of the recent versions (post 2.4.1) and read it for yourselves. Here’s the extracted paragraph for convenience:
Extract from LICENSE-SUPPLEMENTAL.txt
1. Pro Pass
A Pro Pass (.fgpass) unlocks paid features. It is a personal, revocable
entitlement to use those features. It is not a sale of the Software or
of any copy of it, and it grants no right to distribute anything.
A Pro Pass is issued to one person, and is for that person’s use only.
You may install it on the machines you personally own or control - for
example your desktop and your laptop. It is not a site, team, household,
or organisation licence.
A Pro Pass is non-transferable. You may not share, publish, lend,
resell, or otherwise pass on a Pro Pass file or its contents, and you may
not let anyone else use the Software through your pass.
Pro Passes that are shared, published, leaked, forged, or used to
circumvent these terms may be blocked in current and future builds,
without notice and without refund.
A time-limited Pro Pass unlocks paid features for its stated term only.
Nothing obliges the licensor to issue, renew, replace, or keep honouring
a Pro Pass beyond that term.
Explain to me how this conflict of interest is legal or honestly how any of that licensing text is objectively defendable or legally enforceable.
Yes walton we all know the core editor is free for now (just not open sourced, which adds yet another layer of mistrust especially in light of everything that has transpired so far). Yes we know you only pay for the AI. The point is regarding the AI models. It has always been about the AI models. The entire existence of this project has revolved around these damn paid AI models. Access to these AI models is what’s revocable. And by extension what I have been commenting all along about. What everyone has been complaining all along about.
Unfortunately for you Walton, daddy k00gar has already played their cards and shown their true nature. You can continue to defend their actions unconditionally, like you have so far, and will be judged based on your words and actions by the community. As things should be.
Ah yes, and who is the arbiter of that hmm? Someone who can’t take any criticism, is easily triggered, has had a complete 180 mood shift within a few months time and is also according to your own words “more heavily invested than they should have been” in this project? Can that someone be trusted to be 100% objective in their observing of the TOS? Have these supplemental TOSes ever gone through the eyes of a real lawyer? (i know, Claude seems like a nice lawyer ofc, until you actually get into legal trouble, like we’ve seen with that Subnautica 2 situation haha).
I wasn’t even a member, just a free follower, and engaged in zero interaction with the project on Patreon beyond my initial one month of support given back in June, when i still thought this was a nice project. Still, inspires a lot of trust doesn’t it?
Second unmodiefied fungen I see in this week. Will have to add Tag to hide.
If I would want these not having a lifetime license I would buy a one year license for 75 and run my whole library on it.
I’ve also put some of the requested samples under Script Collections, where they shouldn’t bother anyone. I don’t really see much point in releasing a completely clean, unedited script, since anyone can generate the same script themselves. Maybe it could make sense for personal use, though. If it works for you, others will probably like it too.
Thanks for posting these! Though there are more which use ML models and not just heuristics, like the goblin script linked above, plus these two from my knowledge:
Sooo it’s now official. k00gar has categorically retaliated against a perfectly valid license purchase which has not been shared anywhere. In this case it was my lifetime pass.
Seems that they took the bait hook line and sinker with this one. This now confirms and reinforces everything mentioned above (and is exactly the behavior I was expecting from them to be frank). This license was not in violation of anything in their terms and conditions. Let this be a huge PSA to everyone still on the fence about whether to pay for FunGen AI or not.
DO NOT PAY FOR FUNGEN AI. The same utterly deranged individual is responsible for both giving you a license AND taking it away. Boycott this disgusting and likely illegal behavior.
I paid them a total of 130 euros. Now they are asking twice that for a lifetime pass, probably more in the future.
Combine this with the closed source editor where you cannot see what other telemetry is being shared with them, and this is an omega-yikes project. I would urge people to stay away from it, who knows what other shit it is hiding behind the vibeslop. Utterly pathetic.
I do think you were being antagonistic and more critical than I was but that doesn’t justify you getting blocked from patreon and getting a lifetime license you paid for revoked. @walton said
but it’s clear that if you offend the dev he takes your money and your product away from you. This is extremely bad pr but the dev likely doesn’t care because criticism is on a forum he purposefully left to avoid criticism. I imagine his discord doesn’t allow questioning his decisions there’s nothing you can do. It’s sad to see a dev leave the site and do this.