That’s an interesting sleeve holder. Is it worth the price? I tried to look at the other products, but it’s kind of hard to tell what they’re selling.
I wanted to weigh in on the silk sleeve. It is much heavier than the gen2, and also not as stiff, so it collapses during operation there entire time. With that said, it’s silicone, so it can retain a certain amount of heat. And as others have reported, it’s softer. These things taken together, it’s the closest I’ve felt to the real thing.
With that said, it’s not the kind of silicone that is super heat resistant. If you ask the handy folk what you need to do to take care of it, their suggestions are pretty conservative. And I found myself asking because my sleeve got a crack around the top that has worked itself all the way around. I bought it as a closed sleeve, and it looks like it might eventually be an open one.
The Handy folk tell me that they haven’t had many reports of this, or if the (slight, so far) degradation that that I’ve noticed on the top and on a side of the sleeve. It almost looks like it’s been exposed to silicone lube, which shouldn’t be the case - I’ve been pretty careful with it, in general. I had been leaving it under the electric blanket. Maybe that was what did it.
Since getting the handy 2, the sleeve that ships with it - I think it’s a gen3? - has been its replacement. The difference in the diameter of the hole in the gen3 and the gen2 is just small enough that the gen3 is almost uncomfortable. There gen2 was pretty close to perfect. And though I have hit the top of the gen2, I didn’t notice the gen3 was smaller, because it stretches that much more than the gen2 (but not the silk - whose hole is the same diameter as the gen2).
I have not tried the mod sleeves. They looked like torture devices to me.
I’m curious about trying out non handy-co anaholes (with a compatible sleeve adapter, of course.)
Well I’ve gone on a bit. Hopefully I’ve shared some info that can be useful to others.