Can we normalize tagging automatically created funscripts with tools like Funscript dancer. While they can be fun, most of them are not really of quality. I personally also dont want to put each script together with its video into openfunscripter to see “generated by funscript dancer”
7 Likes
I would like this too but I think instead it should require people to say if they scripted frame by frame only or partial or not at all. As I think that’s an slightly easier way of doing the tagging if it’s not made an requirement of writing it in the description which I think should be done instead. (putting it in the description)
I would also like certain things to be required when posting as sometimes length is missing or any preview gif/image of either the video or the script nor a link to the video without an paywall. (rare occurs though)
3 Likes
Maybe it is time to laucnh again this debate to add “Full Generated Script” tag without any kinds of rework after? Or “Hand Made” Tag?
With the recent release as Open of the Funscript generator, we’ll certainly have more and more of this kind of scripts/topics.
Recent example : https://discuss.eroscripts.com/t/old-hentai-anime-digest-3-ovas/253865/1
With strokes > 1000 units/sec, and sometime for no actions on screen
Here an example of 20 seconds on a section with fixed image, nothing is moving on screen, and we have “hell” of actions. (I personally yes filler but to have actions like in middle of sex, not really…)
And endpoints not aligned att all
I’m not against users using this software and share “their work” (if we can call like this), but if need to click on every topic to see if information is here…
A tag should be added I think to let user to make a first sorting / muting to the free scripts list.
4 Likes
Yeah, we need a tag like “untested_AI_trash” in a case like this lol
Don’t want to say “Trash”, but as a scripter, viewing the “code” of these king of generated gives some chills.
But if these people accomodate to this scripts and have satisfaction, so be it (at least 7 persons likes these generated hentai scripts apparently according to the topic)
I think the goals for this is better suited to review scripts quality.
We can encourage users to tag AIGenerated scripts with #AI-generated simply to let others know it was generated.
Or #AI-assisted for being hand made tweaked after.
1 Like
are these tags already existing, AI-generated abd AI-assisted ?
For me, it is all I ask, then I can go mute at least the AI-generated.
You just make them when making a post
1 Like
I understand that this is off topic.
However, it seems as though the discussion is using a video I posted as an example.
The efforts of scriptwriters are valued.
But it is not fair to reject the efforts of engineers because they infringe on the rights of others or do not suit the tastes of scriptwriters.
I have revised my post several times in response to requests to correct the tags.
However,
I have made it clear from the very beginning of my post that “this script was not created by me.”
With that in mind, I felt uncomfortable discussing the content and my post as an example.
Is the image also a yin-yang from a video I posted? I was not consulted beforehand. It’s not a rule, but are manners being observed?
Of course, I understand that the main theme is the pride of craftsmen and the decline in quality due to industrialization.
Don’t want to say “Trash”, but as a scripter, viewing the “code” of these king of generated gives some chills.
I will never forget this comment.This is subjective, and even if you try to take it in a positive way, it’s impossible to overlook.
Maybe we could add a comment like Add the #ai-generated tag if the script was primarily created by AI to the template that appears when people create a script topic.
1 Like
Hello,
Thank you for your message. First apologies to have discuted of your video here. On the moment, I had your video opened in OFS and wanted to do some screens tol illusrtate my message, without thinking. Sorry.
Thank you too for adding the tag to your topic too.
I didn’t want to be rude. But maybe I’m taking scripting too seriulsy since months, and some things get of my nerve quicker.
For me I have started scripting because I enjoyed analyse the videos, putting attention to details: stroke length, endpoints, speed, imagination for some situation. Don’t think this a question of “scripters” taste, but the minimum requirement to respect (at least for non PMV/HMV). Or maybe I’m wrong since I have started scripting?
If I finish a script and I’m satisfied, it’s a win. If I share and have at least 10 likes, it’s another win.
When as a scripter you spend 8 hours to enjoy and answer a request for an anime episode last week, taking time to add details and use his imagination, releasing for free, and in general honored to share with the community since more than 1.5 years, and gets like for the accomplished work, it’s my motive. I think it’s same for others scripters here
But on another side we see topics of creator posting scripts on full generated AI, with no works behind these (or maybe I’m missing something, what is done before or after launch the AI, by a user?), with as output the opposite of why we are taking time scripts: no correct endpoints, uncontrollable speeds, some randomness for the exact same scene with camera changes. As a scripter I’m just seeing that a “random” function used.
For someone who never open OFS or read heatmaps, maybe this can be satisfy. But, as a scripter, sorry I can’t run this kind of scripts, and know I can’t enjoy with my Handy because I already know the actions will not follow what I see.
What’s why I wanted to have a special tag for this, to make a first filter to my list, in no way forbid or ban these scripts. Users can sure freely use them and share their creation. I’m sure we’ll certainly see these cases more and more.
Maybe one day AI will be fully to make correct scripts directly usable, and will I use them? But for the moment the tests I’ve done so far with some are not conclusive for me, with I think I can call it now an “expert eye”. Still some works to do after, I prefer for the moment starts with a empty scripts and pout myself all the elements.
Once again, my apologies if my previous post was kind of rude. Don’t want to throw a cold here, please enjoy our community.
1 Like
I accepted your honest response.
I can clearly see that you have no ill intentions.I think the content itself is worthy of discussion.
I just produced the video and don’t intend to call myself a scriptwriter.
However, when my post is brought up in the middle of a discussion, it seems like I’m claiming to have hand-made something that was automatically created by AI, so I wish people would be more considerate when discussing it in public.
I believe that tool developers should be valued just as much as script craftsmen.
There may be times when our interests do not align.
In those cases, I think it is best to avoid criticism and instead share ideas to have more constructive discussions.
This topic is similar to what has been discussed every time the Industrial Revolution occurred since the 17th century.
I hope your work continues and gets better.