Interesting discussion; thanks to the OP for starting it up. Never let it be said that porn forums can’t host insightful discussions about life, the universe and everything.
@ace fire: I understand. I’ll add an extra dimension in the discussion: in all my relationships, I have never, ever, experienced 1/10th the amount of pleasure that I experience with technology. I’ll come back to that word, “amount”, however (spoiler). But I must start by saying that anyone who disputes the “1/10th”, has never had masturbators, anal vibrators and e-stim devices edge him into oblivion for hours on end; while having the most perfect women on the planet pushing all his brain’s visual “buttons”.
There can be no doubt about this: you will NEVER blissfully edge your brain out as much with a sexual partner, as you can with technology. NEVER.
So, if you are into “relationships” the way they are defined by dating apps - sex-buddy of the day - then, absolutely, yes; technology offers a dramatically SUPERIOR amount of pleasure than what you will get from a “body” you only sleep with one or two times before the inevitable switcharoo.
Now, if we decide somehow to be honest about it, there are side-effects to this technological “thirst quenching”. It removes a vital part - perhaps the most vital part, at the beginning - driving people into bonding: The “Hunger”, the “Thirst”. And that indeed changes things a lot, for many men that suffer from said hunger.
As you said, it allows you to look at women objectively, rationally - and decide to form or not form friendships with them, without the hunger driving you mad.
…and many young men whose thirst has now been quenched, will take a good, long look… and decide to, well, not go there.
Claiming that porn, edging and gooning are somehow not associated with the cliff-like drop in long term relationships is ridiculous. It’s sticking one’s head in the sand. Statistics from the last 10-15 years on marriages and sex between young people are, like, screaming the truth. Hell, women do as well - talk to any young woman and they will tell you about it.
Men that only looked at women as sex objects for “thirst relief” are now dropping out of marriage - and out of society altogether, sometimes - because the thing that defined their entire existence (the thirst) is now satiated - completely. And then some.
And to be clear, @Shownshadow: women - both outside and inside marriages - always know, understand, and… well, “use” the hunger. I am being objective about our reality here: it’s ABSOLUTELY natural for a woman to regulate the sex in a long-term relationship. It is literally how both they, and us, are WIRED. Anybody who has ever lived with a woman knows what I am talking about; pretending this is not the truth, is, again, ridiculous.
The only question that young men should ask themselves, therefore, is this: was your interest in women only driven by the Thirst?
Do you only care about maximizing the “amount” (see? I promised I’d get back to this) of pleasure in your life?
Or do you feel that your life is empty unless you live through the wholesome experience that @edger477 shared? To blend your life with that of another human being to such an extent, that considering life without them is completely crazy? To have children with them and face all the insanity and unpredictability that comes with it?
The answer to that question is a personal thing. There is no right or wrong answer - only right or wrong FOR YOU.
If you are a person that loves his freedom, his ability to do whatever the fuck he likes, who has experienced the modern “dating” scene and felt an overwhelming “FUCK NO”, who wants to be able at any point in time to hop on a plane and live in a different state/country every 2 years… then with your thirst quenched by technology, NO, you don’t need women. And your pleasure needs can be more than adequately addressed with technology. Far more, in fact.
But that may not make you completely happy.
P.S. I started a similar discussion in Milovana, some years ago; but it quickly turned into a shitshow, because people were over-reacting - from both ends of the spectrum. I hope this one won’t suffer a similar end 