Personally I think leaving feedback as replies a good use of the feature. If the forum is about scripts (like everyone else says), then let people talk about the script! Mirroring the upload in another category complicates the feedback process imo. If people don’t bother clicking the blue Reply button right under the script to write something helpful, I doubt they’ll jump between categories to do the same thing (like said above, the category existed but had gone largely unused).
If people don’t want feedback (bruh) they could always ask people to shut.
I like this. I have tried to built something like that but it takes up too much space (you can’t hide polls inside [details] either).
Summary
- option 1
- option 2
I imagine posting polls as a reply will make it equally accessible (like this one). I prefer not to put them in a separate category which requires jumping between pages.
And I’m thinking about this plugin.
https://discuss.eroscripts.com/t/topic-ratings-plugin/127829
There is also an official reaction plugin, which is limited in functionality, but it is something beyond counting hearts.
https://discuss.eroscripts.com/t/discourse-reactions-plugin/131298
There has been some good suggestions in Site Feedback and I hope admins can take some time going through them. It’s the little things that make people engage more often.